Formally Disproving Divine Command Theory

[John V]

Thank you theists for highlighting your problems with the OP.

---

Where does it assert this?

And, where does it assert that saving a life is always right?
An example of this situation in the Bible is Rahab in Joshua 2. She lies in order to save the lives of two men. Joshua later spares her and her family. Further, the NT commends her for doing the right thing twice (Heb 11, James 2). So, the premises of this argument are faulty.

---

It seems like all of you are saying in one form or another that the Bible doesn't say we shouldn't lie.

Incorrect, at least for me. I'm saying that the Bible is against lying in general, but allows us to apply judgment and to lie if the situation requires it to save a life.

What should we do about these verses then?

Take them for what they are: general exhortations not to lie. Mature readers don't need the disclaimer "except in certain extreme life-and-death situations" to be added after each instance.