RE: A challenge about women and marriage in Islam
May 2, 2013 at 9:49 pm
(This post was last modified: May 2, 2013 at 9:53 pm by Violet.)
(May 2, 2013 at 6:48 pm)paulpablo Wrote: I'm arguing that 9 year olds shouldn't have sex it isn't exactly difficult. There's no pleading involved and I'm using the statistics of the person I'm arguing against.
Okay... then I'm arguing that 31 year olds should have sex it isn't exactly difficult. There's no pleading involved and I'd use statistics, only the person I'm arguing against hasn't provided any.
Quote:Which is a better law for most 9 year olds, the one that allows them to legally get pregnant, beaten, distracted or totally brought out of education plus in realistic practical terms results in child abuse and forced marriages coerced by parents and so on.
Which is a better law for most 31 year olds, the one that allows them to legally get pregnant, beaten, distracted, or totally brought out of education plus in realistic practical terms results in domestic abuse and forced marriages coerced by sugar daddies and so on.
... Because I'm totally arguing for legal beatings and bringing peeps out of edumacation, right? RIGHT! I've only denied this straw man six times... are you really that dense?

Quote:Or a law which promotes not having sex with 9 year olds, good parenting education, no domestic abuse and so on, it's actually boring me how little effort I have to put into the argument, as I said I haven't even used my statistics and by the way yes I would say those statistics do result in 9 year olds wanting less sex than 10 year olds based on the information on those charts.
Or a law which promotes not having sex with 31 year olds, good adult education, no domestic abuse and so on, it's actually boring me how little effort I have to put into the argument (NO KIDDING!), as I said, I haven't even seen any statistic used by the opposition, and by the way yes I would say that shying away from statistical usage would result in some hilarious scenario where our charts alter the reality of the world.
Quote:Guess how the majority of mammals on this earth came into being? By their parents having sex. Condoms split, contraception often causes medical problems so they aren't always advisable, abortions are often dangerous and basically it's just better for the 9 year old to remain not pregnant, call me old fashioned that's just how I see things.
Guess how the majority of mammals on this earth cam-- oh I can't do this anymore. Seriously... this is too much.
Really... what is the point of this paragraph?

Quote:My point is the majority vast vast majority of 10 year olds don't have sex, the majority that do, didn't want to and were persuaded by force or threats.
Oooh, look! He has a point. Let's read it! Oh... that was it. Well, that was lacking, given its ignorance of why a majority of 10 year olds don't have sex

Quote:You asked to see these statistics and they are provided to you by someone who is arguing the same point as you, now I paste them in front of you and you ask me what my point is?
Me and muslim scholar are not arguing the same point... I read them, and I thought they were pointless ESPECIALLY given that you have a grand total of three (3!) data points. I ask: why does one assume this data trends at all, let alone the direction of it's trending

Quote:Don't ask me for statistical evidence if you don't want to see it and refuse to see the point in it even if it is right in front of your nose.
I've asked you for it... and I've yet to see it. I'm not refusing to see your point, Buster Brown: I'm desperately looking for anything substantial in your point. And finding... nothing. I might as well make the point that the sky is blue... sure, it is... but: does it matter?

(May 2, 2013 at 6:56 pm)NoraBrimstone Wrote: I just broke my face in an attempt to facepalm and headdesk at the same time.
Don't break it across a kitty on the way down... it'd be tragic to hurt a pussy cat

Please give me a home where cloud buffalo roam
Where the dear and the strangers can play
Where sometimes is heard a discouraging word
But the skies are not stormy all day