Would theists become atheists if we found lifeform

[Neo-Scholastic]

They're more likely to be challenged by the theology of the aliens, or their lack of it. The Abrahamic ones would have to try to figure out if the aliens are fallen or not, I think.

You are exactly right. I often pose this question about it to other Christians and it usually generates much debate. The question is this. If Klingons were real, would they need their own Klingon version of Christ to atone specifically for them or would we expect them to recognize a human savior?