(May 30, 2013 at 7:33 am)Muslim Scholar Wrote:(May 29, 2013 at 4:08 am)little_monkey Wrote: Your premise: S1 is finite.The proposition that S1 is finite is just option of may, I didn't assert that
Your derivation: S1 is not empty, S1 is not infinite.
Your conclusion: therefore S1 is finite.
You can't get more circular than that.
The main conclusion is that S2= ɸ i.e. S2 is empty.
You've started with S1 is finite, then conclude S1 is finite, that's like starting with x=5 to conclude that x=5.
Your conclusion for S2 is likewise circular: you started with S2 is infinite, but then say S1 contradicts it, so it must be the empty set.
Your grasp of logic must be dysmal if you can't see that obvious error.
Quote:Quote:Isn't it that God is eternal (existed an infinite time in the past, will exist an infinite time in the future)? Isn't he infinitely powerful? Infinitely knowledgeable? Infinitely beneficent?No, god created time so he didn't exist an infinite time before time, because this will be non-sense
He will not exist for an infinite time in the future, because at any point of time we can say he existed for N number of years!
So if God does not exist for an infinite amount of time, he will cease to exist, that is, he will die? What kind of God do you believe in? Do you know that in your religion this is heresy and you could be executed under a fatwa?
