I'll just deal with your summary rather than the whole proof:
Not if time is a circle. A circle does not have a beginning and has an infinite number of points. If the circle expands or contracts, the number of points does not increase or decrease because they are infinite.
Your argument is basically "How did we get something from nothing?" Your answer is that we got something from another something called God. So then the question is "How did we get another something that created this something from nothing?" Which is to say that you haven't really answered the first question.
I think that the attributes you suggest for God are entirely by your own preference to fit your explanation.
(March 18, 2013 at 6:44 am)Muslim Scholar Wrote: I'll summarize it in very few words
1- If time is infinite, there must be a time in the past where infinite numbers of seconds passed which is not, so time & universe had a start.
Not if time is a circle. A circle does not have a beginning and has an infinite number of points. If the circle expands or contracts, the number of points does not increase or decrease because they are infinite.
Quote:2- As the universe was nothing or something static, something (else) must have started it to be time sensitive, we will call it G.
Your argument is basically "How did we get something from nothing?" Your answer is that we got something from another something called God. So then the question is "How did we get another something that created this something from nothing?" Which is to say that you haven't really answered the first question.
Quote:3- G must have some attributes, those attributes are not by choice but by logic, so they define G.
G's attributes matches God in Islam
I think that the attributes you suggest for God are entirely by your own preference to fit your explanation.