(July 10, 2013 at 11:23 am)Inigo Wrote: Labels don't matter. Label any position anything you want. All that matters is what arguments can be mustered for it.
Labels do matter. They are how you communicate which ideas and concepts you are talking and arguing about. Otherwise you'd have to keep repeating the entire description over and over again.
Here, for example, you've been incorrectly using the label of 'morality' for your unusual concept - a label already in use for something else, similar enough to confuse everyone and different enough to mean completely different things. Ans so we have 48 pages of discussion of people telling you how and why you are wrong and you repeating that you are right by definition. If you had started the thread by saying that atheism is incompatible with your gmorality - I don't think anyone would have argued against you.
(July 10, 2013 at 11:23 am)Inigo Wrote: You don't solve complicated philosophical matters by getting a dictionary! None of this matters.
If you can solve a complicated philosophical matter by a simple reference to the dictionary - well, why wouldn't you?
