Omniscience Argument Against God's Existence

[FallentoReason]

The equivalent of what you'e saying is that a square-circle must be a square and circle simultaneously by definition, when my hypothetical argument would be that such a concept is a non-starter because it's incoherent.

I don't have time to respond properly right now, but if we're using metaphors to describe our discussion, then it would be more accurate to say you start off with a square, but then start describing it like it's a circle; you keep assuming things about the square that just don't apply to it.