(January 22, 2010 at 3:35 pm)Purple Rabbit Wrote: Why are you not satisfied with the statement MasterDebater just made? Is there any new information in the assertion that he is an atheist that not already is in his otherwise very clear statement? And if there is any new information in the atheist label, why do you attribute it to him without asking?
He said he wasn't sure if he was an atheist or agnostic, so I replied that that statement alone (assuming it's true) makes him an atheist by definition.
EvF