(October 15, 2013 at 4:55 pm)DeistPaladin Wrote: Wrong. I'm not adding to the text.Yes, you are. Watch:
Quote:"These people came to that house to visit so and so" suggests, unless otherwise noted in the story, that the house belongs to "so and so". I think it's fair to say everyone would read it that way but for your need to square it with Luke, whereupon you write a "good explanation" for it.There it is - you added to the text.
In sum, my explanation for the mysterious house is:
"That's his house"
Quote:Your explanation for the mysterious house is roughly,No, my explanation is - it's a house. I don't know whose. Anything more is an explanation to your addition to the text, not the text itself.
"Joseph arrived for the census, went back to Nazareth, then returned to Bethlehem because he got a great job offer and then had to flee to Egypt."
Occam's Razor.
It's a house. We don't know whose. Simplest interpretation. Occam's Razor.