God is timeless

[Ben Davis]

Apologies for the misuse of 'assume', I'll correct my statement: The problem is that the question, as valid as you consider it in theological terms, is predicated on the presupposition of god's existence.

[quote='Ben Davis' pid='555869' dateline='1386259451']
the OP presupposed God's existence in his question, I have no need to prove his existence to answer his question. if I ask "what color is big foot?" do you seriously think i'm looking for evidence of his existence?

Then I think you get my point: many rational atheists see no more value in the philosophical musings on the properties of a 'non-existent' deity than they do on bigfoot. It's like the question "What's the smell of blue?"; essentially nonsensical.