The following is not a question: Can something come from nothing?

[LostLocke]

I'm unconvinced that's the case. You're speaking of the existential beginning of a singularity that he appears to be saying never existed at all.

I think he's saying that the singularity existed, but that the physics concept of time did not coexist with it, hence time references to it are meaningless.

LL: Who's right?

For better or worse, you are right in what I'm describing.