Who throws the dice for you?

[LostLocke]

Premise 1: God exists only if events happen which cannot be explained by local physical causes.
Premise 2: Events happen which cannot be explained by local physical causes.
Conclusion: Therefore God exists.

Premise 1: Sauron exists only if events happen which cannot be explained by local physical causes.
Premise 2: Events happen which cannot be explained by local physical causes.
Conclusion: Therefore Sauron exists.

See.....the issue is that you need to show that God exists before you make any premise that he does exist.
See how that works?