RE: Abortion is morally wrong
August 25, 2014 at 12:16 am
(This post was last modified: August 25, 2014 at 12:24 am by Losty.)
Sugar honey baby doll. This thread is over 100 pages long. If he had a point he probably gave his argument pages ago.
Also, I have read your argument. Several times. The problem I see with it is that you make you're being right a condition before you begin.
Ok so let us make two assumptions
A) a fetus is a moral subject
B) the only way to be responsible for a moral subject is to provide it life
Now here's the argument.
If you have sex and get pregnant then having an abortion is morally wrong.
Well that's not really an argument that's an assertion and the rest of your argument is void because the only reason it "works" is because you made that the condition of the argument in the first place.
So, I will give you A, but I will not give you B.
You're welcome to try to convince me again if you're interested. But if providing life is the only way to be responsible for a fetus then you will need to prove that because I completely disagree with that.
Also, I have read your argument. Several times. The problem I see with it is that you make you're being right a condition before you begin.
Ok so let us make two assumptions
A) a fetus is a moral subject
B) the only way to be responsible for a moral subject is to provide it life
Now here's the argument.
If you have sex and get pregnant then having an abortion is morally wrong.
Well that's not really an argument that's an assertion and the rest of your argument is void because the only reason it "works" is because you made that the condition of the argument in the first place.
So, I will give you A, but I will not give you B.
You're welcome to try to convince me again if you're interested. But if providing life is the only way to be responsible for a fetus then you will need to prove that because I completely disagree with that.