Atheism is unreasonable

[Whateverist]

Actually, both. Before the fight I was prepared for an all out war...I was preparing to punch, kick, elbow, hit with chairs, poles, and bats...but instead I get a referee in the ring telling me that elbows, chairs, poles, and bats are prohibited...I can only punch

Oh, so you were just lying when you said the rules I directed you to sounded good and you agreed to play by them?

More likely he just didn't really think any agreement he made with a known god-hater was binding. You know, being a proud apologist pretty much everything is fair play .. and even more effective if your opponent keeps his agreements.