(November 21, 2014 at 11:17 am)FatAndFaithless Wrote:(November 21, 2014 at 10:46 am)Riketto Wrote: When you said.................... NDE's have produced 'visions' of just about every god............ i guessed that you were saying that if different people see different things in a NDE experience you means that the NDE experiences can not be real experiences.
Real experience would lead to the same result according to your logic.
In my example i show you why (according to me) this can not be the case.
As far as Hindus and Buddhism versus other religions my point was not that the first are right and the second are wrong.
It just refer to the fact that some believe in reincarnation and rehabilitation and the other don't offer this chance.
I've never said a word about 'real experiences', I only made a comment on NDE's. My only point is that you cannot use NDE's as evidence for any god, as every religion has NDE's that confirm their faith to the faithful.
If you would read among the thousand of NDEs you will realize that even non religious people have had these experiences.
I guess many ex atheist keep quite about these experiences in order not to feel a bit embarrassed.
Quote:Great, Hindus/Buddhism have a reincarnation doctrine, I know. What does that have to do with NDE's, and why is it relevant to reality?
Actually the issue about one religion versus the other was related only to the fact that one believe in rehabilitation and the other doesn't.
NDEs came in a different context of argument.