(December 9, 2014 at 9:15 am)robvalue Wrote: Is there a commandment I don't know about that says, "Thou shalt not answer any given question, instead answer another question or ask your own question"?No. For example, just a couple posts above, FAF asked, Are you really going down to the most reduced relativistic level where you really claim to not know why a functioning society is a good thing?
No wait, that's the politician's oath.
And I answered directly: Yes. Actually I went there some time ago. Look at what we're doing to the planet. One could easily argue that the world would be better off without our functioning societies.
FAF asked a valid question from what I wrote. PT OTOH included a non sequitur in his question. As noted, saying that "one could argue" something does not indicate that the person holds that position himself, and in fact indicates just the opposite. I responded accordingly.