My blog

[robvalue]

I see, thank you

Richard Carrier is a mythicist too, I've found his arguments way more convincing than any of the HJ crowd. It always seems to come down to an inference, leaning on motive or just giving too much credit to sources. I'll check out that link though, cheers Do you know what argument / evidence he uses?

A lot of people "conclude" there was a HJ but not once have I seen any actual evidence to back it up. It's always hand waving. That's why I'm trying to see if I've actually missed anything. Just saying "It can't have all been made up" isn't a very strong argument in my opinion. Because it absolutely could have all been made up.