(March 11, 2015 at 8:54 pm)Cheerful Charlie Wrote: I find it a good strong atheist argument against the most expansive arguments for an infinitely powerful God and for naturalism. God as a concept here is very shaky and self-destructs when taken to what as first seems to be the logical limit of omnipotence.
Well spotted, and well explained. I find it to be a very strong argument as well and I was hoping that my OP might bait a theist into being slammed by it. But alas....
I think that this argument is to omnipotence as the Euthyphro Dilemma is to assertions of piety. Thanks for chiming in!
