RE: Proving The Resurrection By the Minimal Facts Approach
July 9, 2015 at 2:20 pm
(This post was last modified: July 9, 2015 at 2:21 pm by Jenny A.)
Randy to prove the resurrection with five facts you must first prove the facts. I give you two of five on that: Jesus was crucified and Paul switched sides after having an experience of some sort. After that you must explain how those five facts prove the resurrection happened. That you have utterly failed to do.
When people find a body missing they don't usually jump to the conclusion it was raised from the dead and for very good reason. That the disciples claimed to have seen him is not particularly credible evidence since we no virtually nothing about them, their credulity, or their veracity. Saul's vision is a vision and proves nothing. If James changed his mind, he did. But that isn't evidence of the resurrection only Jame's state of mind. And your minimal facts don't explain why he changed his mind.
Now you want to add martyrs, eyewitness accounts, details about the exact circumstances of the five "facts" and who knows what else. But you don't have good evidence for those things and they are beyond the scope of the five facts.
When people find a body missing they don't usually jump to the conclusion it was raised from the dead and for very good reason. That the disciples claimed to have seen him is not particularly credible evidence since we no virtually nothing about them, their credulity, or their veracity. Saul's vision is a vision and proves nothing. If James changed his mind, he did. But that isn't evidence of the resurrection only Jame's state of mind. And your minimal facts don't explain why he changed his mind.
Now you want to add martyrs, eyewitness accounts, details about the exact circumstances of the five "facts" and who knows what else. But you don't have good evidence for those things and they are beyond the scope of the five facts.
If there is a god, I want to believe that there is a god. If there is not a god, I want to believe that there is no god.