Atheists answer me

[NoraBrimstone]

see

this is a philosophy but i can clarify little of it

we will focus on the characteristics

example of a door and the woodworker

woodworker makes the door and the door has its own characteristics
then it is not correct to ask who makes the woodworker
because he is the one who makes the door
but we Can say who creates the woodworker

see
door is non lived thing
but the woodworker is alive being

so the questions of from where each of them come is differ

same as asking from where god comes
this question raised because we say god created the man

this question cant be asked
because we dont say there is a common characteristics between god and the human

which is in this situation is that both god and man are created

So if you find a pointy rock by a river, is it pointy because a god made it pointy, or because of erosion from the river?