Ontology of God--Theological Noncognitivist View

[Knight]

You commit yet another fallacy by calling into question my intelligence. Strike 3!

You would be correct if I discredited your arguments based on your intelligence. I did not. The old ad hom. fallacy is thrown around so much on forums it seems people forget what it actually means.

The unicorn having no meaning is the crux of the problem.

The unicorn has told me it has decided to raise the stakes. If you do believe in it, it shall reward you with an eternal life. If you do not believe in it, you shall be tortured for an eternity.

I must go, it is speaking to me now and I must record what is is saying before Almighty Unicorn's Word is lost. But first...

The formulation of the God concept does have meaning, and his transcendental nature is core to his essence. Believing in him has a lot of meaning. Meaning which is emphasised by the necessity for faith in his existence.

How can it have any meaning? You have failed to answer the questions of my previous post.