Can someone debunk this

[The Grand Nudger]

Good luck with that, Camus. If you ask a bullshitter to bullshit you, he's going to accommodate, but is that really what you want?

[Cyberman]

Wrong question.

Is it a wrong question because you have no answer?

No. It's the wrong question because it's a red herring. The apropos question is not how Astreja would correct the 'design', but why the 'design' should require correcting.

[Edwardo Piet]

Some lady was telling my wife where she buys her meat from has chicken breasts so big that one can feed 4 people...

"Some lady" and her 4 person midget family that barely eats is not exactly a reliable source.

[pocaracas]

You really are a sick fuck, Huggy.  How dare you belittle the experience of the innumerable people who have lost family members in such a manner, as well as the people themselves who spent their last moments gasping for breath with pieces of food lodged in their windpipes.

If this is what your religion has brought you to -- snarking about a legitimate medical issue to try to score a point against those mean old atheists -- then you can bloody well keep it.

^^^^Excellent example of fake outrage.

Alright Asteja, since you consider the trachea and esophagus connecting at the throat to be a terrible design, how would you improve it?

You see where your nose is?
And where your mouth is?
And then you see how their functions have to cross over to reach lungs and stomach?

The quick and dirty engineering solution is to simply swap the mouth with the nose... I assume some extra details should be tweaked.... perhaps putting the air intake right under the lower jaw? And have it be more of a wide chamber, instead of a tall one... and instead of sharing glands with the eyes, it would share with the mouth.
Extra point: no more sinus.

[Edwardo Piet]

I didn't realize you atheists struggled so much with eating... I mean infant children seem to have it down pat.

The rest of your post could more than likely be solved by eating proper foods.

You really are a sick fuck, Huggy.  How dare you belittle the experience of the innumerable people who have lost family members in such a manner, as well as the people themselves who spent their last moments gasping for breath with pieces of food lodged in their windpipes.

If this is what your religion has brought you to -- snarking about a legitimate medical issue to try to score a point against those mean old atheists -- then you can bloody well keep it.

See, it's all about quantity of deaths and suffering for fuckwits like Huggy. He doesn't give a shit about how acutely individuals suffer or how awful their death is. He counts the mere quantity of deaths and people who suffer the same way he counts up his stupid fucking prayers for God.

For him it's not about empathy and genuine caring. It's about doing the lord's work even when it's a bunch of bullshit.

[The Grand Nudger]

^^^^Excellent example of fake outrage.

Alright Asteja, since you consider the trachea and esophagus connecting at the throat to be a terrible design, how would you improve it?

You see where your nose is?
And where your mouth is?
And then you see how their functions have to cross over to reach lungs and stomach?

The quick and dirty engineering solution is to simply swap the mouth with the nose... I assume some extra details should be tweaked.... perhaps putting the air intake right under the lower jaw? And have it be more of a wide chamber, instead of a tall one... and instead of sharing glands with the eyes, it would share with the mouth.
Extra point: no more sinus.

A solution we find well represented in other creatures.  Making it;s absence in our own "design" all the more baffling.  If you wanted to follow it to it;s logical terminus..we could only assume that god wanted us, specifically... to choke to death by design. 

Allah hu Akbar!

[Huggy Bear]

Is it a wrong question because you have no answer?

No. It's the wrong question because it's a red herring. The apropos question is not how Astreja would correct the 'design', but why the 'design' should require correcting.

We must first figure out IF the design CAN be corrected to determine if there is even a flaw...

So once again, how would you improve the design?

---

^^^^Excellent example of fake outrage.

Alright Asteja, since you consider the trachea and esophagus connecting at the throat to be a terrible design, how would you improve it?

You see where your nose is?
And where your mouth is?
And then you see how their functions have to cross over to reach lungs and stomach?

The quick and dirty engineering solution is to simply swap the mouth with the nose... I assume some extra details should be tweaked.... perhaps putting the air intake right under the lower jaw? And have it be more of a wide chamber, instead of a tall one... and instead of sharing glands with the eyes, it would share with the mouth.
Extra point: no more sinus.

How does speech factor into this design?

[henryp]

No. It's the wrong question because it's a red herring. The apropos question is not how Astreja would correct the 'design', but why the 'design' should require correcting.

We must first figure out IF the design CAN be corrected to determine if there is even a flaw...

So once again, how would you improve the design?

It's all silly.  The real question is if the design could have come about without a God.  The answer is yes, making this whole tangent unimportant.

[Cyberman]

We can see from other creatures that the single tube 'design' isn't the only engineering solution, particularly in upright species. Evolution can only work with what is already available; a designer has no such restriction. If humans are supposed to be "God's" culmination, the apex, of its design, please account for the inadequacy.

[Cyberman]

I'm glad to see that nobody is fooled by Huggy's Herring.