The problem with Christian "evidence" is that the evidence isn't actually in support of what they claim it supports. If you feel, for example, that under certain conditions some unknown entity is watching you or protecting you, then that's a feeling. That feeling is evidence-- but not for God. It is evidence that people respond to certain situations with certain feelins.
So when someone says, "God entered my heart" and a hundred other people chime in "me, too," this is not evidence for God.
So when someone says, "God entered my heart" and a hundred other people chime in "me, too," this is not evidence for God.