(November 24, 2016 at 3:15 am)robvalue Wrote: I don't think it's reasonable to insist someone believes in the supernatural when a coherent definition hasn't even been formulated.
Quite honestly, I'd never tell a theist what they have to believe. From my point of view it's all made up anyway, so I don't particular care what the details are. I'll debate them on their terms.
God is rarely defined coherently either. Ignorant's version makes more sense than most; even if it seems to me to be a set of abstract concepts.
It is exactly the same behavior as a believer who comes here and tells us what our atheism means and what failings we must have as people on that account.