A Conscious Universe

[Neo-Scholastic]

[quote='ChadWooters' pid='864152' dateline='1422983909']I never said that meaning was preassigned. People can still find their own meaning and still be a part of something larger than they can even imagine.[quote='Mister Agenda' pid='864916' dateline='1423067488']…your exception for 'ontological naturalists' is puzzling. Would you elaborate, please?

A while back I got hammered for equivocating atheism with ontological naturalist even though 99.9% of atheists tacitly accept it. For the study of nature, methodological naturalism right limits its inquiries to matter [material cause] and efficient cause. Formal and final causes are not considered. Ontological naturalists make the metaphysical claim that only material and efficient causes exist. Physical objects and events are not ‘about’ anything. They just are. For the ontological naturalist the apparent intentional behavior of some things, from thermostats to human beings, is an illusion. That means that any concept that hinges on intentionality, like meaning and purpose, is also just a phantasy. Thus, the ontological naturalist that says their life can have meaning is contradicting himself or herself.