Well I would say that we already know that someone put dice in ONE of them at least.
If we had no reason to think there was dice in ONE of them; then why should we look?
Would we go searching the planet for trancendent dice? I Don't think so.
The thing is if this is meant to be an analogy it is a false one because the default position in it is to assume that there is trancendent dice in one of them. Or at least SOMEWHERE.
With God however; untill there's any evidence or reason to think there's a God ANYWHERE. Why would we assume that maybe there IS a God but perhaps we just can't detect it?
Unless I have misunderstood?
We may not be able to tell the difference between a trancendent invisible God and no God...but there's no way we can tell the difference between a trancendent invisible FSM and no FSM either.
Until there is any evidence of God why think there is one? And if there is no evidence of God or his effects; practically there's no difference anyway.
trancendent dice on the other hand. DO exist. Whether we can tell exactly where they are in that test...or not.
If we had no reason to think there was dice in ONE of them; then why should we look?
Would we go searching the planet for trancendent dice? I Don't think so.
The thing is if this is meant to be an analogy it is a false one because the default position in it is to assume that there is trancendent dice in one of them. Or at least SOMEWHERE.
With God however; untill there's any evidence or reason to think there's a God ANYWHERE. Why would we assume that maybe there IS a God but perhaps we just can't detect it?
Unless I have misunderstood?
We may not be able to tell the difference between a trancendent invisible God and no God...but there's no way we can tell the difference between a trancendent invisible FSM and no FSM either.
Until there is any evidence of God why think there is one? And if there is no evidence of God or his effects; practically there's no difference anyway.
trancendent dice on the other hand. DO exist. Whether we can tell exactly where they are in that test...or not.
