(January 26, 2016 at 9:05 am)MrNoMorePropaganda Wrote: AtlasS33, if you want contradictions I'm sure I can provide some. For example in the other topic where the person was talking about the Sabians. Quran says Sabians (who it was claimed worshiped stars) will go to Jannah. This is despite the fact that the Quran mentions star worship as a specific example of Shirk. Anyone who commits Shirk cannot enter Jannah so that must mean the Quran is contradicting itself.
You can search my posts for the Iyah I cited. It wasn't too long ago in that topic about Muhammad by that person who got banned.
The Sabians mentioned in the verse, are a subject of debate.
Some Muslim scholars said they were a sect in the Christian faith, another opinion is that they're an ancient group of people that existed before Judaism and Christianity. I collected those statements from famous ancient scholars. Those opinions include the sayings of "Ibn taymeya", "Tabari".
Though nobody mentioned their relation to star worshiping. The sources I have are in Arabic.
