trancendent dice

[Edward]

Theists would argue that they can see the dice and would marvel that you cannot. They would try to point to evidences that the dice exist, but because the dice are transcendent those would never amount to proof, just evidence. To the theist, the athiest is either blinded by Satan, or willfully blinded, or is cursed and thus spiritually blinded. The problem for the theist is not the invisibility of the transcendent dice, it is the blindness to the dice that has to be remedied.

And keep in mind the most important thing: in this hypothetical thought experiment, the dice are real.