Xenophobic?

[robvalue]

I think it's perfectly fine to discuss and criticise a particular religion without having to talk about all of them. "Other religions are dumb too" isn't much of a defense. Yeah, they are. They're all dumb. So what?

If anyone generalises all Muslims though, I'm going to stop listening pretty quickly. You just can't do that. The only thing they all have in common for sure is that they call themselves Muslims. That's the only requirement, after all. No one has any authority to say who is and isn't a Muslim. Well perhaps one, but he's unavailable for comment.