(April 25, 2017 at 11:28 pm)Neo-Scholastic Wrote:(April 25, 2017 at 2:53 pm)SteveII Wrote: I am claiming that the premise: "It is logically possible for God to create a world where everyone always chooses good" is broadly logically possible.
Actually, I would say the opposite. It is logically impossible for God to make a perfect creation. Creation could only be perfect if it was identical to God. However, creation would be unlike God in that it would be a contingent being. Therefore, creation could not be perfect.
You just admitted a flaw in claiming a perfect being. There is no "impossible" in the word "all" when claiming "all powerful".
If it is impossible for God to make a perfect creation, then it cannot be claimed to have an "all powerful" attribute.
This is just bullshit dodging on your part to prop up a bad claim.
If God is perfect and all powerful then there is nothing that should stop him from making a perfect creation.
If you are going to claim "all powerful" then fucking own it or admit it is bullshit.
I'd say the real reason you try to justify this horrible logic is because you merely like the idea of having a perfect sky hero. This is just you trying to have it both ways to avoid the flawed claim.
