(September 10, 2011 at 6:19 pm)aleialoura Wrote: Last night I had a very passionate religious debate with a Christian. She was, of course, a creationist, who argued when I showed her clear evidence of evolution etc, that she could no longer look at the evidence because it would anger Jesus.
She went on to claim that being an intelligent person is a "curse".
Is this where we are, Christians? Really? I seriously want to know if other Christians think that being an intelligent person, who values evidence and facts over a book that was written when men still thought the sun revolved around the earth is cursed. If so, who cursed us? Why?
This is not the first time I've heard this from a Christian, but they've never been able to answer my questions that follow. She tried to answer by saying that being intelligent is a curse because it turns us away from the bible/lord, but if I am a creation of god, why did he create me to be intelligent? Why didn't he make me stupid? Also, by saying this, is it not saying that Christians are stupid? That's what it sounds like to me.
From a Christian perspective:
1. "I seriously want to know if other Christians think that being an intelligent person, who values evidence and facts over a book that was written when men still thought the sun revolved around the earth is cursed. If so, who cursed us? Why?"
It is not a curse to be intelligent. It's a curse to lack humility. If you cannot end a fight without saying the last word, if you cannot submit yourself to rules, if you simply cannot apologize, then you lack humility. A person lacking humility can never respect the saving power of Jesus Christ, because it calls for people to confess with their own mouths that they have done wrong in their lives.
The fact that these men knew nothing about the stars or the movement of the animals in the ecosystems around them does not mean they were not witnesses to this person Jesus Christ. Also, science presents us with compelling information about the beginning of the universe, the movement of men and the body. What science book can break down how to mend the heart? What can astrophysics do to give hope to people who suffer? What logic book provides us with a way to pray and love people who are beyond loving? What good does it do to compare logic, numbers and calculations with matters of the human spirit?
Think about it, do people apply logic to "crimes of passion"? It is apparent to me that the spirit and science are separate and must be handled that way.
1. "Why did God create me to be intelligent"
The Lord gives everyone gifts. Some are gifted in intelligence, some are gifted with their hands, some with words, all people have been given gifts. The Lord gives us a mind so that we can use it, he has no problem with you constantly questioning and challenging. He will answer all of your challenges when they are real, but if you have wrong motives, he has no reason to show his face to you, because you are not interested in seeing it, your motives are elsewhere.
2. "Why didn't he make me stupid?"
This depends, do you want to be stupid, I'm assuming, like Christians? Do you feel if you were "stupid" you could believe in God? Are you saying that your intelligence stops you from having faith because the evidence for evolution is so overwhelming compared to the claims of the Bible? Have you ever considered having faith in God, even though there are facts supporting evolution?
3. "By saying this, is it not saying that Christians are stupid?"
From the story you described, it sounds like your friend does think that Christians are stupid. For someone to respond with something like, "I can't read this, Jesus will be mad at me." Unless it's forbidden (sorcery, soothsaying, fortune telling, occult participation) then that is a very immature statement to make, and a young Christian would definitely say something like this. "Young", not by age, but by experience and time spent in Biblical teachings.
4. Lastly, how do you get into these fights? Are you seeking Christians to argue with, or are you just running into them? I really am interested.
Usually, when I resond to you, you get a little edgy. I'm saying all of this calmly, I'm not trying to jump down your throat. I'm answering your questions as a Christian and I'm doing it because I think that you really have a desire to know. I'm asking my own questions too and I'd appreciate it if you answer.
When I read your posts, you sound like someone who is burned, by many things. You sound like you've had tons of "friends" who are "Christian" and yet the moment you challenge them, they walk away from you. I didn't like that your friend said you were "sick." I don't think a difference in opinion is sick, nor do I think someone not willing to back down is sick. I don't think you should be judged by your body, nor by your mind. I think you should be judged by your character, which as we know is produced from your life experiences and how you choose to respond to people and circumstances.
I won't back down, unless I'm dead or you become unreasonable.
Salty.
Hobbies Note: I read books about the occult from a Luthern minister who counseled former members of the occult on all levels and sides. I do not participate or read occult participation books.
"And without faith it is impossible to please God, because anyone who comes to him must believe that he exists and that he rewards those who earnestly seek him." Hebrews 11:6