So finally tried making a classical piano song. . .

[chimp3]

I don't know shit about music but why would anything you just created qualify as classical?

I'm feeling the love! 

Classical technically means archaic, as in having Greek philosophical leanings-- especially being very formal.

In music, Classical technically refers to Haydn , Mozart, and early Beethoven.  This certainly wouldn't be a classical piece in that sense.

But my piece is classical in the sense that it's for piano, has for the most part traditional voice-leading, and a pretty simple ternary form in related keys.

So.. you just wrote it  right!