(October 10, 2018 at 12:33 pm)RoadRunner79 Wrote:(October 10, 2018 at 12:04 pm)Mister Agenda Wrote: You claim that an actual infinite can't exist. It necessarily follows that if God exists, it is not an actual infinite. Maybe potentially infinite in some ways, but not an actual infinite. It's only a trap if you're trying to have it both ways and won't admit that your positions contradict each other. It's a binary question can be answered simply: either God is not an actual infinite (in any way), or God is an actual infinite (in at least some way or ways). If it's the latter, in your case, there's a contradiction with your position that no actual infinites can exist, while the first option would be consistent with your position on actual infinites.
The question is genuine, I just want to find out your position on the matter; because there's an apparent contradiction between an infinite God and 'no actual infinities'; which can be resolved if God is only infinite in ways that aren't actual. I'm also curious about whether you will choose to answer forthrightly or evade giving a real answer. You won't 'lose points' if you don't believe God is an actual infinite, it would only establish your consistency. And I'm presuming here that you don't believe in a God that is incomplete in any way, which is why I haven't pressed on that issue'; feel free to correct me on that if I'm mistaken.
I already answered in the 2nd post (I believe) in this particular series. I'm not claiming an actual infinity in respect to God either. If you just say that God is incomplete, then I ask in what way (so I can clarify my position better). For one it may depend on how you are using the term incomplete.
I was pretty specific that I am not claiming God is incomplete. If God is not or does not contain any actual infinites, the issue of completeness is irrelevant as it is not a contradiction. Thank you for the direct answer.
I'm not anti-Christian. I'm anti-stupid.