RE: Evidence for a god. Do you have any ?
December 25, 2018 at 10:07 pm
(This post was last modified: December 25, 2018 at 10:11 pm by GrandizerII.)
(December 25, 2018 at 8:41 pm)Dimmesdale Wrote: I exist too. I believe the existence of "myself" is self-authenticating. But even though it is incontrovertible, for another person it may not be incontrovertible insofar as their "opinion" goes. Some may deny it altogether and not even give a hearing to it. This is in spite of the fact that they suppress what is self-evident. I do not say that that is my opinion, though it can be taken as such, but I believe (rightly) that it is the truth.
One has to take into account standards of evidence, and not everyone possesses the same standard of evidence. For someone who rejects things like logic and things that are self-evident, forms of authority and so on, it may be impossible to even begin with the preliminaries of formulating an argument, a justification for beliefs.
Let's go beyond my own existence, how do I believe in other minds (besides my own) at all? There is a consensus among most human beings that there are other minds. We at least act as though there are. But what is the proof of this? At bottom, we only believe it because it is accepted, because others believe it, or due to some kind of existential knowledge. So let's extend that sort of scope of what is evident regarding the divine. I believe, based upon similar common sense, that some kind of Supreme Being or Essence exists, and that knowledge of this being, even only that of a "bare-bones" variety, is natural to our reasoning capacities and personal psyches. I extend my standard of evidence broader than others. And I more than believe, I know, that I am correct and others (atheists) are not, in this regard.
No, sorry, you don't get to argue that because solipsism isn't reasonable that therefore atheism isn't reasonable. There's a world of difference between not accepting the clear existence of other people and not believing in the existence of some magical being for which we have no evidence whatsoever that it exists (and for which we have a plethora of good reasons to reject its existence).