Is "Be the part of the change you want to see in the world!" bullshit?
February 2, 2024 at 6:18 am
Many people, including me a few years ago, say stuff like "Be the part of the change you want to see in the world! Capitalism allows us to fix the world's problems by being careful about which products we buy!". Now I think that is mostly false. That is, it's true in theory. Obviously, capitalism allows individuals to address world's problems, much more so than communism does. However, the problem is that the average person's understanding of the world's problems is bad, and many people are doing ineffective or even counter-productive things in an attempt to fix the world's problems.
For example, many people are boycotting sweatshops. But it is difficult to see how boycotting sweatshops could do anything but make the problem of global poverty worse. People are in sweatshops voluntarily, so they think the alternatives available to them are even worse. And they are probably right about that. They certainly have more insight into the situation in their country than we do.
A few years ago, I was worried about global warming, so I stopped drinking cow's milk... to replace it with rice milk. Whether that's helping is hard to tell. It's certainly not helping significantly. Both the production of cow's milk and the production of rice milk emit huge amounts of methane.
A few years ago, I was worried about superbacteria, so I stopped eating meat... but I continued eating eggs and, later, I even started drinking wine. The biggest user of antibiotics these days, by far, is the egg industry, not the meat industry. And the industry that uses antibiotics the most irresponsibly is the vineyards: antibiotics stay in the ground forever, forever causing antibiotic resistance, and it's just a matter of time before the genes for antibiotic resistance spread from bacteria which attack plants to bacteria which attack humans via horizontal gene transfer (as bacteria can conjugate with their quite distant relatives). Vegetarianism addresses neither of those two things.
I was wondering what you thought about that.
Let me be clear that I am still not against capitalism, I think that capitalism is the best economic system compared to others that have been tried from time to time. I just think that perhaps it doesn't really make it easy to address the world's problems.
For example, many people are boycotting sweatshops. But it is difficult to see how boycotting sweatshops could do anything but make the problem of global poverty worse. People are in sweatshops voluntarily, so they think the alternatives available to them are even worse. And they are probably right about that. They certainly have more insight into the situation in their country than we do.
A few years ago, I was worried about global warming, so I stopped drinking cow's milk... to replace it with rice milk. Whether that's helping is hard to tell. It's certainly not helping significantly. Both the production of cow's milk and the production of rice milk emit huge amounts of methane.
A few years ago, I was worried about superbacteria, so I stopped eating meat... but I continued eating eggs and, later, I even started drinking wine. The biggest user of antibiotics these days, by far, is the egg industry, not the meat industry. And the industry that uses antibiotics the most irresponsibly is the vineyards: antibiotics stay in the ground forever, forever causing antibiotic resistance, and it's just a matter of time before the genes for antibiotic resistance spread from bacteria which attack plants to bacteria which attack humans via horizontal gene transfer (as bacteria can conjugate with their quite distant relatives). Vegetarianism addresses neither of those two things.
I was wondering what you thought about that.
Let me be clear that I am still not against capitalism, I think that capitalism is the best economic system compared to others that have been tried from time to time. I just think that perhaps it doesn't really make it easy to address the world's problems.
