(December 28, 2011 at 1:55 pm)downbeatplumb Wrote: Would this be an argument for or against god? you could argue both ways.
1: There is life on another planet, the universe teems with life so earths special relationship is null and void so no god.
2: Life on other planet is proof that the universe is 'fine tuned' for life therefore god exists.
There may be other arguments but what do theists think?
For theists that "this proves god" is a forgone conclusion from any argument. This is why debating them is much the same as debating a tape recorder.
