I will prove to you that God exists

[Sheldon]

If the universe is "fine tuned" for life, why does 99.99... % of it kill us (too hot, too cold, no atmosphere, toxic atmosphere, radiation etc.)

Puddles fit the hole they're in exactly every single time, if they differed at all that water could not fit in the shape we observe, that must mean that those holes are fine tuned then? 

It's always funny to see creationists beg the question, and not even realise they're doing it. That certain fundamental constants of nature, and initial conditions of the universe are remarkably precise, does not mean they are created that way, why would it? This question seems destined to go unanswered. If the universe were fine tuned, or even created, this would not in and of itself represent objective evidence for a deity, again, why would it? This question also seems destined to go unanswered. Here are a few more...

1. How does Drew know any other type of universe is possible? 
2. How does Drew know the universe we currently observe hasn't always existed in some form?
3. How does Drew claim to know, that life different to the carbon based life we currently know of, couldn't have emerged in a universe, where these very precise and extremely narrow parameters of the universe we currently observe, might have been different?

So Drew, I don't know you very well, but from this thread, we've had your fairly strident claims, and some obviously fallacious arguments, now I have to ask, are you open minded enough to honestly address critical questions about those claims, and the fallacious arguments you used?