Where do atheists get their morality from?

[Red Celt]

I'm curious, are you using modal logic to make your argument? That might be why we are not seeing eye to eye here.

I'll repeat what I told you previously: you know philosophy, but you don't know it well enough. You take the knowledge that you do have and use it as a shield, trying to convince others that you're a philosophical genius. I'm guessing that you've done it often enough, that you've managed to fool yourself, too.

But... no. Philosophy is what I do for a living.

I'd rate you at a C- "Must try harder".