You said eternal praiseworthiness (God) is more greater than anything on earth (ie. including earned praiseworthiness) and that he can bestow that gift (but no one has been worthy of it). I find it contradicting a little bit, that someone has to be worthy of being bestowed a gift and it being a gift at the same time, but since this a minor point, and is irrelevant to your disagreement to the premise "earned praiseworthiness is always greater than unearned praiseworthiness", it's not an issue.
There wasn't much reasoning provided as far I can tell as much as disagreement with the premise.
There wasn't much reasoning provided as far I can tell as much as disagreement with the premise.