Argument from evil, restated

[John V]

You're going off on a tangent. The subtle point I made was that God's justice isn't something practical between humans. The wronged party is not involved in the process. It's merely the criminal and a butt hurt god who knew his creation would go against him, and yet the criminal can potentially walk away while the wronged party hasn't benefited in any way. It's a ludicrous concept that's devoid of any substance, just like most things in Christianity e.g. a sacrifice which was undone by the sacrificed reclaiming what he sacrificed. Everything revolves around your god basically interacting with itself.

The problem is that you're trying to mix god's mercy and grace into his justice. The resulting system does of course seem ludicrous, as justice is deserved, while mercy and grace are undeserved.