Would this be decent evidence for reincarnation?

[Zone]

Is the alternative - totally new incorrigible fools are born every day - better than the theory of reincarnation, which suggests the same flock of fools returns time and again to screw with the world?

Perhaps it's cunning a way of keeping incorrigible fools locked up in physical bodies of matter where the harm they can do is limited or something, I don't know. Reminds me of this rather cool HP Lovecraft story where this guys soul goes off to kill some kind of cosmic space alien.

If he really were reincarnated, why wouldn't he get 100% of the details 100% correct?

We don't necessarily remember everything in our own lives 100% correctly so there could be some scrambling or confusion or perhaps two different lives mixed together.