(November 11, 2013 at 5:30 am)bennyboy Wrote:Exactly!(November 11, 2013 at 5:13 am)Muslim Scholar Wrote: No, it means that God did the first event
An infinite number of anything is impossible (by logic)
What was God doing before he "did the first event?" If nothing, then creation was his first event
Quote:, i.e. his birth into time, and a being who is capable of experiencing events is not timeless after all.This has no meaning!
God therefore did not create time, since he's subject to time.
Therefore, he did not create all of spacetime.
Therefore, he is not all-powerful by necessity: whatever he is, and created, must be a subset of (him + his creation + time). Therefore, God is not God. Or, more simply, not God.
What is your definition of time?