Replacing Religious Morality

[Neo-Scholastic]

You seem to agree with my opinion of a vast dichotomy in logical behavior in a world with and without a God.

I do, thank you.

With eternal...do you think it's odd that God would be so coy in regards to his existence?

I consider God's existence to be pretty obvious.

I'm certain there is no God, and am attempting to live accordingly.

Certainty can be elusive. I go with what I consider reasonable. Even though I think God's role in the world is fairly obvious, I can and do still have my doubts.

Is that my fault, or His? Particularly when he could have just popped his head in a window like he used to do for the old-timey folks and say "Nope, I'm real. Sorry for the confusion."

It would be your fault, because He did come into human history to "say hi".

Even if I were going the agnostic route, we both agree it's an impossible position to take. There is no 'maybe there is a God' way to live.

I cannot say that I agree, because I don't really understand what you mean. Could you expand on this idea a bit.