The Million Dollar Question

[lordofgemini]

You just said universe in a different state existed before that. So there is a before that obviously. U can keep thinking like this won't reach an end. Until you take out something to be eternal.

Yes there may have been a "before" the big bang, even though time we understand it did not exist. We know now that this universe in its current will suffer a cold death which it will last forever

All I am asking you to do is use logic. Something must be eternal in the equation. Otherwise nothing would make sense.