RE: Refuting misconceptions:3-Authenticity and preservation of the Quran
June 29, 2010 at 1:24 pm
(June 29, 2010 at 1:02 pm)annatar Wrote:lol am just showing you that this will get us to nothing there are a lot of rules when trying to check the authenticity of hadith(like history) and there is a lot of rules when using hadith the first thing is to compare it to the Quran if it is under the general rules given you can get to the next rule and if not you can totally ignore it.Quote:what make you sure that he even said this?so you are a sceptic now. but still you can easily accept that quran never changed although the fact that just few people knew by hearth the original quran at muhammed's time. Anyway every hadith i used is written by known scholars among muslims. Even muslims accept that they are true hadiths. btw you want me to search if its true. yet you use hadiths so easily in your arguments.
there wasnt few people who memorized the Quran there was a lot(get back to my main thread under memorization) and it was written anyway. in the war of yemama only 70 died(in this time there was more than 10000 muslims in madina only)
am not using hadith in my arguments except for rules as hadith is used as an advice but if you used shura its the same(specially if there is unauthentic hadith)
at last if you are searching in religion you have to use the book claiming to be revealed from god if there is a prove you will find it there not in hadith or history books(this applies to all religions)