RE: Refuting misconceptions:3-Authenticity and preservation of the Quran
June 30, 2010 at 3:40 pm
Quote:dude lets see what happened when i mentioned about herritage error;no you claimed that the verse is talking about one situation and then when i clarified this you started talking about the situation you thought is in the Quran
first you claimed that i am puting different situations together.
Quote:then you said "you are making a mistake by not taking into consideration that the children share is from the remaining after parents take their share"yes i made a mistake by telling that children take from the remaining(i found it was not children its the son only)
then i showed you this is not the case.
Quote:at this point i think you did "some search" and you changed your argument from "there is no mistake" to "but they are fixing it" &"quran only gives general rules" which is realy absurd and I explained to you why this is absurd in related thread.yeah i really did a lot of search as i didnt have the knowledge about the avl lol
if you want to prove me wrong that in the Quran we are given general rules you must give me a rule in the Quran that mention every possible situation then i will admitt that in the Quran we are sometimes given all the rules in every detail even exceptions
Quote:You are not objective when it comes to your religion my friend. You didn't even checked if my calculations are true or what i said is real you simply rejected at the begining. And that is my friend what we call "blind faith".your case from the begining was based on a very clear mistake you made(i dont know why you dont want to admit it) which is thinking that the verses you mentioned is all talking about one situations and this was the thing that was supposed to be refuted and not to get in details about islamic sharia which is not based on the Quran only (it is the rules under the general rules of the Quran) but i found that you are interested to know and i had curiousity to know about what you say so i didnt just refuse it without a reason there was a mistake in your claims and a misunderstanding about how sharia and islamic law works
about the blind faith you cant say this untill you tell me that the reasons that make me believe is not real and prove it wrong