RE: Refuting misconceptions:3-Authenticity and preservation of the Quran
June 30, 2010 at 5:35 pm
(This post was last modified: June 30, 2010 at 5:54 pm by annatar.)
Quote:no you claimed that the verse is talking about one situation and then when i clarified this you started talking about the situation you thought is in the Quranreally now?
let me clarifiy this then. you said
Quote:lol you are adding different situations to each other the first situation is if a man died and left 2 daughters or more and thats it there is no wife mentioned or parents the parents is mentioned in a different situation in the rest of the verse. not all the situations are mentioned in the Quran but we were given general rules that when used you can know what to do in all the situationsthen i said;
Quote:no it is not different situations... are you saying one cant have a daughter, mother, father and wife at the same time???I was aware that i was talking about one situation as you see. i never said the verse is talking about one situation.But one of the situations has this error.
and keep saying general rules. As you said that verses gives you solutions for all possible situations. and same verses gives you a solutuon about my situation either and it has an error which you cannot fix without violating verses. According to quran you cant change quran's direct orders and this is a direct order.(i love circular logic right now) At this point if you are objective you should consider the possibility of you being wrong.
Quote:yeah i really did a lot of search as i didnt have the knowledge about the avl lolokay i said avl but i defined it as a constant which is used to fix this error. if you could read you would see that. and of course no one can give every possible situation about herritage sharing. becouse one can have so many children but you can give a condition just as quran did you can say if you have 2 daughters or more And can yougive me a verse that allows you to vioate qurans verses? Becouse thats what awl do.(i answered your last post in simple mathematical error thread please write your answer there.)
if you want to prove me wrong that in the Quran we are given general rules you must give me a rule in the Quran that mention every possible situation then i will admitt that in the Quran we are sometimes given all the rules in every detail even exceptions
(June 30, 2010 at 4:40 pm)Paul the Human Wrote: But, you are going to believe it is true until someone proves a negative. Delusional.
even if you prove it(which i did with this mathematical error) he will keep believig.
Quote:Many that live deserve death. Some that die deserve life. Can you give it to them, Frodo? Do not be too eager to deal out death in judgment. Even the very wise cannot see all ends.
Gandalf The Gray.