'downbeatplumb Wrote:This is like saying your chances of winning the lottery are 50/50 either you win or you wont.
It discounts all the other possible explanations for everything and reduces them to a binary either or which they aren't
Incorrect, There is a chance that both can happen, there is not a chance that God can both exist and not exist depending on random chance.
Just as your birth mother is your real birth mother, or is not your real birth mother. Its either true or its not true, its not possible for both to be potentially true or false, unlike the lottery