Systematically Dismantling Atheism

[JonDarbyXIII]

And at every step along the way an intelligent life form that is 1% superior in intelligence/attributes can logically & rationally exist from the perspective of the life form that is 1% inferior, and at no point along the way does this chain of slightly superior life forms become an irrational concept .... Therefore in this chain of logically possible life forms, the existence of life form 100000^100000 (i.e creator of the universe, thus God) becomes as logical a concept as life form 1.1 is.

Fatal flaw in the argument: this supreme being is not "as logical." While it is possible that a being could exist at every incremental stage in the increase of superiority, the probability of such a being existing decreases with every increment. It is not inconceivable that a being 1% more superior than us could exist; however, it is very inconceivable that a 'supreme' being could exist.

Second, I should point out that the argument only leads to the possibility of God. While there are some atheists who strictly say that there is definitely no God, most say that while it is possible that there is a God, there is no evidence for it. I acknowledge the vague possibility of a deity, but I have seen absolutely nothing in my life that supports as anything more than a wild supposition.