Systematically Dismantling Atheism

[Asmodee]

I understand your position perfectly. You keep restating it and asserting that I MUST not understand it if I don't agree with you. This is not the case. I simply don't agree with you.

-and then you proceed to argue against some other point.....

Christ, will you lay off already? I understand what you are saying. I disagree with it. It's not that I'm too stupid to get your point, it's not that your point, if I understood it, would change my mind. It's that I disagree with the point you are making.

We do not know our own minds, at least, not fully. We know our own minds better than anyone else does, though. That fact alone is enough to make me accept that if someone is telling me that their position is that they are agnostic, that is probably their position.

Agnostic agnostic - the double double. The super nuetral nuetral (as I put it earlier in the thread) - the person who says they do not know whether or not they believe. I haven't been arguing that a person can't be an agnostic. I've already stated that people can be agnostics...................this is why I have to keep restating it - because you keep fucking it up when you respond.

If a person knows their own minds then they know what they do not know.

I'm not so arrogant or stuck on my own beliefs to think that I know better than they.

No, you're just arrogant enough to tell someone else what they're arguing rather than let them tell you- repeatedly.

And you're arrogant enough to tell someone else what they believe rather than let them tell you. We're both a couple of arrogant fucks and we're both wrong.